BY SEAN WALSH
Are you suffering from mental health? If so then try play and prayer!
Do you or anyone you know “have mental health”? If so, it seems that you are entitled to the sympathy of many of us who don’t.
I ask because somebody I know was in tears after her daughter was “diagnosed with mental health”. I put to her that surely that is a good thing but that didn’t seem to help and instead seemed to incur the disapproval of others present.
As I say, I don’t “have mental health” myself, prone as I am to cycles of depression. I’m not wishing to be churlish but it seems to me that people who do have it should be a bit more grateful.
There seems to be a proliferation of diagnoses when it comes to mental illness. Almost as if they’re breeding. Like autism hooked up with Asperger’s one night and ADHD came along nine months later.
It will not be long before there is a new addition to the medical dictionary with the diagnosis of a fresh condition which causes the sufferer to collude with the benefits system in identifying as having all and only those conditions which can only be treated via the prescription of cash. You may not have ADHD but could be that you suffer from a different condition that makes you think you have if the money is right.
I am not saying that these conditions are not real. Take ADHD. Anyone who has spent any time in a classroom recently will have noticed the lack of attention span, the behavioural issues, and the addiction to screens. Clearly this is a genuine affliction given that so many teachers seem to suffer from it these days.

Does NOT have imaginary mental health.
One person who is famously sceptical about all this is Peter Hitchens (above), for whom the new medical conditions, along with some of the more established ones, are not real things but are instead the results of linguistic error. Mr Hitchens’ attitude to autism, for example, is reminiscent of the logical positivists’ attitude to religion: that it’s nonsense arising from the misuse of language.
Not just autism either. Mr Hitchens is similarly eliminativist when it comes to dyslexia and is sniffy about the addiction as disease philosophy. He’s also funny about clocks.
In fact it might be amusing were somebody to arrive late for an appointment with him and blame it on not putting the clocks back because his or her dyslexia meant they couldn’t read the reminder and in any case they were coming from an AA Meeting. I wonder if at this point Mr Hitchens’ head might explode and we could ask what’s left of him whether or not that counts as a genuine medical event.
I have some sympathy for Mr Hitchens’ scepticism which seems to have its origins in common sense. There is something too easy about the way in which medical people persuade the rest of us by linguistic or nominative fiat. The assumption seems to be that because we have a name for a thing there must be a thing to which that name attaches.
The philosophers, ironically, have a name for this error. They call it voluntarism, the mistake in believing that language or belief is (ontologically, metaphysically, or logically) prior to what is being discussed or believed.
But it is also possible that Mr Hitchens is making an error of his own. There are real things which language can only get to the essence of by approximation. And there are particular instances of general things which can only be grouped together because it seems they belong together.
This was, I think, what Wittgenstein is getting at when he talks about games and family resemblances. Some games involve rackets, whilst others don’t. In some games you aren’t allowed to punch your opponent whilst in others, such as US ice hockey, you absolutely must. If there is an essence to the concept of “game” then it’s not possible to give it in a list of necessary and sufficient conditions.
The same might be true of the new illnesses, in which case Mr Hitchens is being too cynical.
The deeper problem with the “mental health” fascination is theological, of course. We are conditioned now to think of our minds as objects to be studied and potentially medicalised. In truth we are not consciousnesses but souls. The soul, Aquinas tells us, is the animating principle of the body and not the other way around.
So, while it is true that we did not have so much ADHD or “mental health” back when we were growing up that might be not because we are attaching new labels to old things but because through habits of play and prayer, and with no high tech Ouija Boards mobile phones to turn into, we were more concerned with the care of the soul. Even if we didn’t know it at the time.
Always look to the older thinkers for the truths we need today.

