Let Us Bray

Listen to this article

BY JOHN NASH

In case you missed the miserable little event, Dear Reader, the annual round-up of Eduardo Gonçalves’ last willing donkeys was held in the Hall of the Westminster Asylum on the 11th November, where a few of the pitifully loving but brainless creatures could be seen circle-stroking each other in a display of mutual admiration, combing each other’s piety like baboons grooming each other. It was, as always, misleadingly described as a Debate on Hunting Trophy Imports, but it was neither a debate nor about trophy hunting—just a weird little sect meeting to wallow in the rapture, totally unaware they are Eduardo’s advertising props, much like the PG Tips chimps. I watched with matchsticks propping my eyelids, wearing a sturdy truss so I wouldn’t rapture myself should I fall comatose from my chair.

You may recall that this particular Westminster sect and the UK movement that feeds its self-appointed druids were set up by the oily genius Eduardo Gonçalves, uber-parasite and eco-bandwagoner of note. Remember, too, his previously successful excursion, the “SOS Save the Iberian Lynx” campaign, where he gained fame and fortune by pretending, in the UK, to be the saviour of the Iberian lynx—an unfortunate wild moggy that declined to less than 100 animals in 1992 after being declared vermin by Franco and losing its food supply of rabbits to myxomatosis. Luckily, the endangered creature was successfully saved from the brink by captive breeding (to number over 2,000 now) through ample funding from the European Union’s LIFE Programme and the efforts of the governments of Spain and Portugal, IUCN, ICNF and others. Oily Ed had sweet Fanny Adams to do with any breeding or reintroductions of the lynx, but he basked in glory, and I’ll bet he noticed MEP Caroline Lucas’ success in levering serious funding out of the European Parliament. Endangered animals can move mountains—of money.

With the lynx saved and well on its way, Oily Ed’s bandwagon stalled. Then, in proof that the Devil looks after his own, the Prince of Darkness laid before the perfidious Portuguese Prince of Propaganda the body of the infamous Cecil the Lion. “Cecil” was an old lion, hunted when it was pushed out of the Hwange Reserve by younger, tougher lions and ended up in the hunting ground buffer zone outside the park in 2015. He was given great invented posthumous fame by enterprising heart-tuggers. Global outrage ensued. Tears flowed, and so did money. Oily Ed was no doubt onto it like a tramp on a sandwich. Forget the lion—fate (or Lucifer) had just sent him the biggest global pantomime villain imaginable in the form of a rich, evil, cruel, dastardly trophy hunter in a pith helmet.

By 2016, Oily Ed was CEO of the LACS nut-orchard, where he was up to his political and cash-collecting tricks again, interfering in the deceptive but very lucrative UK fox hunting debate. It was now that he put two and two together, peered into the Aladdin’s Cave of potential, and launched the deceptively brilliant Campaign to Ban Trophy Hunting (CBTH) in 2018, combining the modern endangered animal industry, animal welfare, environmental concern and his Victorian villain.

This was a triumph of political subterfuge. Celebs, knowing nothing beyond limelight, flocked to it for its unlimited free virtue signalling, and by 2019, Oily Ed’s CBTH donkey farm was growing well inside our UK Parliament. MPs now piled on, parading their own free invented virtue, publicly exorcising Oily Ed’s pantomime villain with the faithful ferocity of the Archangel Michael putting the Holy Boot into Satan. It spread like St Vitus’ Dance—political parties were soon fighting in an undignified heap to be first to get a ban on trophy imports into their PR manifestos.

Thus was Eduardo’s modern cash cow born, fighting an imaginary villain in the flickering limelight of a Victorian music hall. The sect won’t give up, because the villain they hate is inside their heads, not outside in reality. They call it protecting wildlife—everyone else calls it schizophrenia.

Which brings us to the annual round-up on the 11th. It was opened by the eminently asinine Clive Efford, who is MP for the mythical rolling savannahs and jungles of Eltham, where thundering herds of imaginary wildebeests and zebras fire his hyperphantasia. He addressed the herd like the music hall compere in The Good Old Days. Sadly, Dear Reader, in his earlier life he imbibed the intense knowledge of a London taxi driver, and it shows… it left little room for anything else in his head, so he now speaks from his other end.

His opening statement was a masterpiece of British irony, quoting St David Attenborough’s “It’s what people did in the 19th century. One would’ve thought people would’ve got over that.” They did, but don’t let that affect this motley collection of half-wits. It was Efford’s preface to three hours of tilting at a very old windmill, as, ironically, one after the other, they stood to excoriate the evils of Victorian White Hunters, apparently unaware that the hunters they describe disappeared along with gas lights and horse-drawn carriages. With furious laments more suited to discussing The Man Eaters of Tsavo (1907, Patterson) or A Hunter’s Wanderings in Africa (1881, Selous), they might as well have railed against children up chimneys.

No one mentioned today’s vast, global, scientifically regulated hunting conservation industry. They took turns to quiver and dribble biscuit crumbs, castigating their Victorian pantomime villain, unconcerned with trivia like the real world, land use, population expansion or the modern conservation dividend. In the end, it was rather sad—a bit like watching confused old souls in the lounge of a dementia care home, listening to Vera Lynn singing war songs.

Efford spoke with great weight; after all, the world’s clouds weigh a million tons. He was on cloud nine, totally oblivious to the fact that he was following Oily Ed’s script, nit-picking facts so far from earthly truth they were more satellite launches than kite-flying.

The thrust of their political argument is this: because a ban is on every party’s manifesto, we must now “stop talking and get the ban into law.” Unfortunately, that’s the problem—all of the UK party manifesto bans were based on the heady rapture of those early fiery sermons, not on cold reality. The morning after Oily Eduardo’s eco-revivalist meetings, sane people and proper politicians suffer a hangover as reality dawns. A ban would be indefensible in a court of law. Not one of its claims holds up scientifically. It ignores the voices of Africans. It is based on a porky-pie. Worse still, a ban would do untold damage to animals, people, conservation and biodiversity in Africa, despite its popularity as a bumper sticker. That’s why their script calls for a ban “Now!”—before anyone examines the facts—they know that science and simple justice would dry up their wet dreams faster than Tena Lady pants.

Nobody in the room, least of all Mr Efford, even mentioned Africa’s great parks, where animals are protected and not hunted. The zealots are fond of quoting Kenya and Costa Rica, where “hunting is banned,” but look closer. Why ignore South Africa? Because Costa Rica has 13,000 sq. km of parks and Kenya has 58,000 sq. km of parks, but South Africa has 112,000 sq. km. Nobody will be running out of wild animals just yet, so they simply ignore it.

The really interesting stuff is outside those protected parks. Kenya has lost up to 80% of its wildlife outside its parks because, without paying hunters, wildlife has no value and is quickly replaced by cows, goats and camels that do have value for locals. We wait to see what happens to the wildlife in the unprotected 75% of beautiful Costa Rica.

Now look past the silly pantomime to today’s modern industry and South Africa, with its 112,000 sq. km of protected parks, full of glorious wildlife that you are strongly encouraged to visit with your Brownie box camera. But outside those parks (and studiously suppressed by Oily Ed and his donkeys), modern farmers raise wild animals in natural bush for hunting, meat and live sales on ranches up to 100,000 acres or more. That’s where most UK hunters go. These “game farms” total a staggering 205,000 sq. km of private hunting grounds. That’s twice the area of the nation’s protected parks, all of it extra bush, all filled with wildlife. The whole of South Africa is owned by people—you can’t just go there and shoot animals willy-nilly any more than you can in the UK.

That vast farming area, all private property and all wonderful land use, also supports billions of indigenous plants and animals in their natural surroundings that are not hunted, tripling the country’s biodiversity estate without charity or government support. The average cost of conservation across Africa is around £750 per sq. km, so the game farms save the government and world NGOs some £150 million while producing thousands upon thousands of tons of free-range organic meat and countless jobs. That is a genuine conservation dividend and an economic benefit, but of course it doesn’t exist in Oily Eduardo’s Victorian scenario. These are real ranches where hunting is both sustainable and regulated, where the very finest animals are bred for stud (what farmer shoots his best stock?), and the animals are all increasing in number because skilled stock farmers can raise as many as needed. No wonder they suppress it.

It’s a vast £600 million modern industry, with its many, many millions of conserved wild animals that are not “endangered animals,” yet Efford, like his master, pretends otherwise. Every hundred thousand harvested antelopes yields a hundred thousand sets of horns, too, but dippy Efford wants us to spitefully ban the UK importation of about a hundred a year, just to act the White Knight and fill Gonçalves’ piggy bank. The industry works in Africa because regulated human hunters have replaced the unregulated natural predators, and ranching wildlife far exceeds the five freedoms demanded of animal welfare on UK farms. And, of course, all the animals that are harvested are eaten by the locals. It’s Africa, not Islington. Africans eat elephants, rhinos, giraffes, zebras and everything else.

And talking of elephants, you won’t be saying goodbye to the last one any time soon—there are probably 300,000 across Southern Africa, suggesting 100,000 too many. They eat about 4,500 tons of the local shrubbery every week. So, under strict permits, a few are culled and some are sold to hunters, not even scratching the 20,000 born every year. The meat goes to the locals, and the Westminster donkeys are unaware that a ton of meat from one charismatic elephant means a ton of lots of other, smaller, less charismatic but more endangered creatures won’t get eaten instead… reality marches on.

And, Dear Reader, this account covers just the first few minutes of a ridiculous charade. Three hours of nonsense about “rich white hunters murdering and mutilating Africa’s precious creatures” followed. I wondered idly if a few lions released among these dopey, tinfoil-hat conservationists might liven up the proceedings a bit.

Be blessed.


John Nash grew up in West Cornwall and was a £10 pom to Johannesburg in the early 1960’s. He started well in construction project management, mainly high-rise buildings but it wasn’t really Africa, so he went bush, prospecting and trading around the murkier bits of the bottom half of the continent. Now retired back in Cornwall among all the other evil old pirates. His interests are still sustainable resources, wildlife management and the utilitarian needs of rural Africa. John is the co-author of Dear Townies with the Editor.