BY CALUM CAMPBELL
White-Tailed Sea Eagles and Eider Ducks
The white-tailed sea eagle, once driven to near-extinction along the Baltic coastline by DDT and industrial chemicals known as PCBs, has made a remarkable recovery since those substances were banned. Numbers have climbed to approximately 2,000 birds across the region, increasing at a rate of 8 per cent per year according to a 2016 study (University of Helsinki). For conservationists, this represents a triumph over environmental degradation. For the eider duck, however, it represents something altogether different.
Each adult sea eagle consumes approximately half a kilogram of meat per day. Multiply that by 2,000 birds and the scale of predation becomes apparent. Studies of nest remains in Scotland have identified up to 73 per cent of 1,930 prey items as birds, with the sea eagle recorded killing some 170 different avian species (National Geographic; University of Helsinki). The eider duck has borne the brunt of this predation along the Baltic coast. The International Union for Conservation of Nature now classifies the eider as “Endangered” following what researchers describe as a precipitous decline.
The eagles target nesting hens with ruthless efficiency—either diving upon nesting areas to flush the birds from their nests before killing them, or hopping from one juniper bush to the next until a hen loses her nerve and attempts flight. When hens are flushed, corvids and gulls swoop in to take the eggs. The eagles consume eggs as well. In some regions, hen eiders have abandoned traditional coastal nesting grounds entirely, moving inland to attempt nesting in woodland—a behavioural shift that speaks to the intensity of predation pressure.
The eagles’ hunting methods extend beyond nesting colonies. Male eiders and other ducks are subjected to repeated attacks on the water, forcing them to dive repeatedly until exhaustion sets in and they are caught and killed. Observers have recorded sea eagles making as many as 65 passes over water in 45 minutes attempting to catch ducks. One observation documented 15 to 28 attempts to catch a single little grebe. The size range of prey is remarkable: sea eagles have been recorded killing mute swans weighing up to 14 kilograms, yet will also target little stints weighing a mere 62.6 grams. Caspian tern colonies—a threatened species—are targeted with chicks eaten one by one. Lesser white-fronted geese have been reduced to a single breeding colony; when sea eagles appeared in 2012, numbers at that colony fell from 150 to 60 in a single year. One white-tailed sea eagle was observed targeting starlings by flying directly into murmurations and catching the birds one at a time. On the Estonian island of Hiiumaa, up to 26 individual sea eagles have been observed simultaneously attacking cormorant colonies. Perhaps most striking is the data from a 12-kilometre-wide study area in the Baltic, where 1,000 to 2,000 ducklings would typically be observed. In 2012, sea eagles moved in. Just 41 ducklings survived.
These Baltic findings carry particular relevance for Scotland, where the white-tailed sea eagle has been reintroduced and is expanding its range. On the west coast, farmers report losing as many as 150 lambs annually to eagle predation—a claim that rewilding advocates dispute. The broader concern, however, extends beyond livestock. As one observer notes, nature does not balance itself out. Apex predators target the easiest and most numerous prey species; when that prey becomes scarce, the predator simply moves on to whatever it can catch. There is, in the current regulatory framework, no get-out clause, no mitigation measures when things start to go wrong, and no politician or conservationist willing to advocate for a cull—such a proposition being far too controversial.
The Swedish land manager who sparked this investigation had watched capercaillie numbers decline on his land. His assessment of proposed lynx reintroductions was blunt: “Don’t do it. The people proposing the reintroduction don’t know what they are talking about.” This scepticism finds support in the Baltic data. The Guardian newspaper has recently reported on the damage high sea eagle numbers can do, and the comment sections beneath such articles reveal a public increasingly willing to question the orthodoxies of rewilding. The evidence from the Baltic suggests that releasing apex predators without mitigation measures leads to trouble. As sea eagle numbers continue to rise in the UK, the question is not whether there will be consequences, but whether those consequences will be acknowledged—and addressed—before it is too late for species already under pressure.
Calum Campbell is a commentator on rural and environmental issues in Scotland.
References
National Geographic. (n.d.). White-tailed sea eagles eat birds.
University of Helsinki. (n.d.). Can there be too many eagles?
Millington, R. (n.d.). Personal communication cited in source material.
Additional source material: 2016 study on Baltic sea eagle populations; IUCN Red List assessment of eider duck.

